Light bounces.

Sunlight comes through a window, hits a red rug, and some of it ricochets up to paint a faint pink glow on a white wall. It keeps going, bouncing off the ceiling, the bookshelf, your face, splitting and softening with every redirect. A single beam ends up everywhere, and every surface in the room is lighting every other surface. Since you’ve seen this your whole life, you’d really only notice if it stopped.

Which is exactly what happened when Pixar tried to make Toy Story in 1995. Simulating light that actually bounces meant tracing billions of rays per frame, and no computer on Earth could reasonably do it.

So the light in early computer animation traveled from a light source to a surface, and stopped there. No bouncing. No red rug glowing onto the wall. Rooms lit this way look flat, airless, and like a stage set.

Pixar's solution was just to fake it.

Since light couldn't bounce, artists hand-placed dozens of beams. A real room might be lit by one window; a Toy Story room might contain fifty invisible lights, each one simulating a beam that the computer couldn't calculate. A dim orange light tucked near the floor to imitate sunlight reflecting off wood. A soft fill hidden behind a character's head to fake the ceiling's glow. Lighting a scene was less like cinematography and more like counterfeiting.

For rigid plastic toys, the result was convincing enough to hold up, which is part of the reason early animation was mostly toys, bugs, and monsters. The real trouble came with making skin look realistic, which turned out to be much harder than plastic.

Skin looks different because light sinks in instead of just bouncing off.

Cup your hand over a flashlight and your fingers glow red. That's light scattering around inside, and exiting somewhere else. Every material like this, like skin, grapes, milk, or wax, has a soft inner glow that your brain interprets as organic. Graphics researchers call it subsurface scattering, and early computers couldn't handle it. But without it, characters came out looking like dolls carved from plastic. Audiences couldn't articulate the problem, but they felt it instantly.

Cracking subsurface scattering took the industry years. By Ratatouille in 2007, Pixar was using it everywhere, which is the reason the food in that movie looks edible.

The endgame came in 2013 with, fittingly, Monsters University. Computers had finally grown strong enough to start simulating light rays as they actually bounce from surface to surface, a technique called global illumination.

The cost is honest, at least. A single finished frame can take a full day of computing. Pixar renders them by the hundreds of thousands, on a farm of machines, to make light do what it does.

Paying over $25/mo? You haven't met Tello yet.

Go to Tello.com Now

Got a second? Give some feedback on today’s article so we can keep making improvements to The Manifold.

PS — Sometimes you just have to fake it til you make it.

1000s of people are already building their own apps with AI. Justin Burns shows you exactly how, live, in 3 days. No code, no dev team. Totally free. Register for the summit.